A scenario analysis approach is discussed in the paper as a means of incorporating climate risk into investment decision making, followed by some of the challenges presented by integrating climate risk analysis with traditional investment risk analysis.
In an increasingly complex and uncertain world, investment decision making is a challenging task. Climate change is adding an additional risk factor because of its potential impact on every step of the investment decision process, complicating matters further. In recent years, climate risk analyses were typically performed by sustainability teams, remaining quite disconnected from the work of traditional investment and risk teams. However, this is starting to change with results and insights from climate risk analysis and from traditional and investment risk analysis being combined and integrated to drive investment decision making.
This paper starts by discussing how a scenario analysis approach has become central for incorporating climate risk into investment decision making and then goes on to discuss some of the challenges that are presented from integrating climate risk analysis and traditional investment risk analysis.
It discusses how using probabilities in climate scenarios is problematic, due to the lack of empirical guidance and the fundamental or radical uncertainty associated with climate risk. It then highlights questions about consistency when combining traditional risk and return analyses with insights from deterministic climate scenario analyses. It also looks at risk and return assumptions and how, in the case of climate risk, the absence of an empirical basis becomes a limiting factor. It concludes by looking at the different data sets available and how the result of any sensible modeling exercise should always be interpreted in the light of the assumptions that were formulated at the outset.
Related Insights
-
17 December 2024Assessing the climate risk exposure of pension funds and insurance companies worldwideAccess a series of Ortec Finance reports to examine how climate risk exposure and resilience vary among pension funds and insurance companies worldwide
-
17 December 2024PRESS RELEASE: US pension plans report possibility of increasing contributions despite improved funded status8% of pension plan managers say their funded status has improved over the past year, study shows
-
03 December 2024Climate risk assessment – European insurance companiesLearn how climate change impacts European insurance companies, via an analysis on a reference portfolio that represents their average asset allocation.
-
03 December 2024PRESS RELEASE: US pension plans set to increase spending on scenario modeling, says new survey
US pension plans see room for improvement on their current scenario and risk modeling activities.
-
02 December 2024Ortec Finance warns on impact of climate change on European insurance company investmentsOrtec Finance releases inaugural insurance climate risk report, analyzing the average allocation of a European insurance company derived from the EIOPA.
-
02 December 2024Charting the unpredictable: Harnessing data-driven solutions to enhance investment decision makingDiscover how pension funds are navigating challenges including ageing populations, DC transitions, climate change, regulatory shifts, and market uncertainties.
-
27 November 2024Ortec Finance warns of the impact of climate change on pension fund returns worldwideOrtec Finance releases inaugural global pension fund climate risk report, analyzing publicly available data from 150 pension funds in the US, Canada, UK, the Netherlands and Switzerland.
-
26 November 2024Defined Benefit (DB) pension buy-out under climate stressExplore the potential impacts of climate and transition risks on DB pension scheme buy-outs with climate scenario analysis
-
26 November 2024Should climate change's impact on liabilities prompt life insurers to adjust investment strategies?Explore the interdependency between liabilities and assets from a life insurer’s perspective and how to adjust investment strategies for optimal performance