A scenario analysis approach is discussed in the paper as a means of incorporating climate risk into investment decision making, followed by some of the challenges presented by integrating climate risk analysis with traditional investment risk analysis.
In an increasingly complex and uncertain world, investment decision making is a challenging task. Climate change is adding an additional risk factor because of its potential impact on every step of the investment decision process, complicating matters further. In recent years, climate risk analyses were typically performed by sustainability teams, remaining quite disconnected from the work of traditional investment and risk teams. However, this is starting to change with results and insights from climate risk analysis and from traditional and investment risk analysis being combined and integrated to drive investment decision making.
This paper starts by discussing how a scenario analysis approach has become central for incorporating climate risk into investment decision making and then goes on to discuss some of the challenges that are presented from integrating climate risk analysis and traditional investment risk analysis.
It discusses how using probabilities in climate scenarios is problematic, due to the lack of empirical guidance and the fundamental or radical uncertainty associated with climate risk. It then highlights questions about consistency when combining traditional risk and return analyses with insights from deterministic climate scenario analyses. It also looks at risk and return assumptions and how, in the case of climate risk, the absence of an empirical basis becomes a limiting factor. It concludes by looking at the different data sets available and how the result of any sensible modeling exercise should always be interpreted in the light of the assumptions that were formulated at the outset.
Related Insights
-
18 November 2024Ortec Finance appoints Koen de Reus to Head of Client Servicing, Climate & ESG SolutionsKoen de Reus will lead a team of climate risk professionals to help financial institutions measure, manage, and monitor their portfolio’s climate risk exposure.
-
07 November 2024Exciting updates for our international Client Conference formatAnnouncement of some updates regarding the Ortec Finance annual International Client Conference.
-
30 October 2024How AI can help manage insurance portfoliosLearn how our Scenario-Based Machine Learning (SBML) approach enables insurers to optimize complex objectives by training AI on thousands of simulated scenarios, uncovering high-performing portfolios traditional methods might miss. Discover how AI-driven scenario analysis is transforming insurance portfolio management.
-
29 October 2024Quarterly Outlook: Q3 2024The outlook is based on the Ortec Finance Economic Scenario Generator (ESG) and offers our perspective on recent developments in the economy and capital markets.
-
01 October 2024Ortec Finance appoints Maurits van Joolingen to head Climate & ESG SolutionsMaurits van Joolingen will be responsible for Ortec Finance’s climate scenario analysis tool to support the risk management needs of financial institutions.
-
16 September 2024Solving the Illiquidity ProblemHow can pension funds cope with this liquidity crunch? Fund managers and trustees need a new toolkit, first to understand the current and future illiquidity risks they face, and second, to identify ways to manage the illiquidity problem. To address this challenge, we teamed up with our client CalPERS to work on an approach to help capture liquidity dynamics in our ALM model.
-
11 September 2024How to improve stress testing for climate changeLearn how financial institutions can understand and prepare for extreme climate risks with climate stress scenarios
-
03 September 2024Beware how financial markets are pricing in climate riskAn inconsistent approach and general lack of understanding is heightening risk
-
15 August 2024Think Tank - A climate-informed investment approachLearn how leading institutional investors are addressing climate risks at a special Ortec Finance event held alongside the 2024 PRI-in person conference